Such was the case for crypto project Bancor this week, which saw its design decisions and strategy picked apart on social media as it sought to contain the damage from a multimillion-dollar hack.
Then on Tuesday morning, Bancor published details of the breach: a wallet used to upgrade smart contracts was compromised and used to steal 3.2 million of the platform's own BNT tokens, 25,000 ETH and 230 million NPXS tokens.
Perhaps most notably, Bancor said it had frozen BNT tokens to prevent their loss.
Some background: it was Bancor that raised a then-record-breaking $153 million in a token sale, which saw participation from investors like Tim Draper and the investment firm Blockchain Capital.
As an early mover in using the initial coin offering funding model, Bancor has long been a magnet for critiques.
Included in the Bancor code is a mechanism that allows the company the ability to freeze movements of the BNT token - something that critics quickly pounced on as the antithesis of the "Decentralization" mantra, by which a network wouldn't have one governing force.
On June 20 of last year, Wertheimer wrote in a Medium post that both Bancor's token and ICO contracts allow Bancor to arbitrarily issue, freeze and even destroy any BNT tokens whenever they want.
Wertheimer further argued that such "Backdoor" mechanisms that undermine the decentralization principles in Bancor could also cause the current breach, as the compromised wallet existed for the purpose of upgrading smart contracts - another feature allowing Bancor to manage the network in a more centralized manner.
One observer suggested that those criticizing Bancor might feel differently if it was their funds at risk following a hack.
Stressing once again that user funds weren't compromised, Bancor said that the funds were stolen out of a BNT's connector balance that served as a reserve, and smart contracts accessed by that wallet.
$13.5 Million Hack Ignites Fresh Debate Over Crypto Project Bancor
gepubliceerd op Jul 15, 2018
by Coindesk | gepubliceerd op Coinage
Coinage
Recent nieuws
Alles zien
Blockchain Bites: Bitcoin's Run, Uniswap's Hemorrhaging Value, Anchorage's Banking Bid
Bitcoin is nearing all-time highs in price and market cap last set three years ago.
Japan's megabanks to lead experiment with digital yen
We have, in order, Cheese Bank with a $3.3 million theft, Akropolis with its $2 million loss, Value DeFi with a whopping $6 million exploit and finally Origin Protocol's loss of $7 million.
Number of new Bitcoin addresses spikes amid growing FOMO
Japan's three largest banks, as part of a group of 30 private sector actors, are set to collaborate on an experiment with a digital yen.
Not just Wall Street: Quant trader explains why Bitcoin price is going up
Sam Trabucco, a quantitative trader at Alameda Research, believes four general factors are pushing up the price of Bitcoin.